No Soap: The Verdict

For January I tried an experiment. No soap when washing myself.

Here are my results & thoughts:

  1. The first week or so is the worst. My body was obviously flushing something out. I don't know what, but it smelt pretty bad. I had a lot of showers per day.
  2. The first couple of weeks I also got quite a few blocked pores, but they went away too.
  3. Even with a very active lifestyle, it's actually quite manageable. I started by using no deoderant (I wanted to know what was going on), but ended up using an eau de toilette under my arms. There wasn't a strong negative smell, I just preferred it to myself. Oh, I hate my body smell, quelle horror. Not really, just a minor preference.
  4. Interestingly, my (very slight) eczema flared up a bit when my body was detoxing, initially, then calmed right down, went away & hasn't come back at all.
  5. When I get out of the shower I'm actually drier. As with the toxin flushing, I suspect that even using a very light soap & rinsing well leaves enough of a film that a) toxins can't naturally flush & b) water gets trapped on the surface rather than naturally being absorbed
  6. I've also stopped using shampoo. Hair feels fine. There's a little grease when I run my hand through my hair, but I figure that's just healthy natural oils. It's certainly never been too oily, not like when I was using shampoo. My scalp is great.
  7. It's really easy to be lazy & just stand under the shower, but it's important to rub your hands over your body, same as if you're using soap — particularly on high sweat areas — thighs, chest, armpits, back.
  8. Ears. Ears are weird. In ears & behind ears? Couldn't keep those clean without soap. I don't think I have particularly dirty ears (unless they're running off while I'm asleep), I suspect it's just a function of the way ears are (you know, waxy & all)

rubber_duckies.jpg
pic by jciv

By the end of the month, I'd settled on using soap in the following circumstances:

  1. Before preparing food (duh)
  2. After bathroom (see? not a complete philistine)
  3. To wash extreme amounts of grease/grime/etc off my hands, or, for example, after vigorously rubbing my scalp to keep my hair/scalp clean
  4. In high sweat areas if there was strong smell or I felt compelled to (after super heavy exercise) — so, that'd be arse, groin, armpits, oh, & the ever magical ear. Even then, I'm using the lightest amounts possible, and very rarely, maybe once a week

Given that my skin is my largest organ (ooerr), & obviously there was something unhealthy being blocked by using soap, I'm very happy to continue with the above plan. That pretty much works for me.

Oh, & for bubble baths? All rules are off :)

[earlier post: The No Soap Experiment]

related

  • Lisa

    fascinating! I am intrigued!

  • http://sidawson.org Si Dawson

    Given that it's been another month or so, I'd say it was definitely the right decision. Everything is now VERY calm. I'm using soap very VERY minimally. Any smell I might have had has disappeared altogether. I'm still showering & washing myself (as if with soap) with water — to remove dead skin cells, of course :)

  • http://giannii.com/ giannii

    test comment #giannii

  • Josef D

    mmm, very interesting concept, might try it out myself. one less thing to buy on student loan :)

  • http://talkanatalka.blogspot.com Talka

    how interesting! i actually stopped using soap for most showers (barring extra-gross circumstances, like massively dirty or sweaty workouts) about a year or so ago…i can't believe the difference it makes on my skin! i no longer have hideously dry skin, and i break out much less often (i only use soap on my face about once a week). it's incredible! i didn't notice a detoxing period as you did…but i wasn't looking for it either, i suppose

  • http://sidawson.org Si Dawson

    Awesome. It's quite interesting actually, everybody seems to have a pretty similar response (when they stop using soap). Which is reassuring — it means it's just about a specific body type, or skin type. No, it really is all about the soap.

  • toshilove

    …a mild dish soap should rinse of with no residue.     Baking soda in water is a good way to get the …"old man " smell— out of the scalp and feet.   Don?t forget that dry skin brushing and a wet towel wipe-off is the best for exfoliating toxin impregmented skin.

  • http://twitter.com/JohnSBaxter John Baxter

    Interesting about the detox. I haven't used soap for a bit more than a week now and have not had to change my habits and have had no side effects…
    except the ears! I wipe them with a wet chux a few times a day and they seem pretty good, but have had a few pimples pop up.Mind, previously I used pretty modest amounts of shower gel (+ said chux) so was probably low-impact already.
    Haven't fully stopped shampoo yet… Oh, and the beard takes some doing, gotta be really rough and have shampood. I hope getting something like an abrasive mit will address that.

  • http://sidawson.org/ Si Dawson

     *nod* yep, I reckon friction is key, no question. As toshilove mentions, dry skin brushing is also good.

    Cool that you're not having any side effects (or toxin flush outs). Think you're bang on, re being already low impact.

    Generally these days I shampoo.. I dunno, once every few months? Only when I'm exposed to ridiculous amounts of dirt (eg climbing around under the house). Hair seems as normal & healthy as it ever did when I shampooed daily.